All editions of Bytes and Insights

Bytes and Insights ·

The De-Screen Movement, What Educators Need to Know About CIPA, and Media Literacy From the Pope!

De-screening policies, CIPA compliance, media literacy, and AI energy demands.

The De-Screen Movement Is Gaining Momentum

Across the country, a new policy conversation is gaining traction, one that could significantly reshape how technology is used in K–12 education. Legislators in multiple states are now considering proposals that would heavily limit, regulate, or even ban certain uses of educational technology in classrooms. What began as a broader societal discussion about youth screen time is increasingly moving into state legislatures and education policy debates.

For school technology leaders, this moment deserves attention. Even if these proposals are not currently emerging in your state, the momentum behind them suggests they soon could be.

A Growing Legislative Trend

Almost a dozen are now considering legislation aimed at limiting digital technology use in K–12 learning environments. Proposals range from daily instructional screen-time caps to restrictions on digital devices in elementary grades.

Some proposals go even further, potentially affecting:

  • Digital curriculum platforms
  • Online learning environments
  • Accessibility tools for students with disabilities
  • AI-supported learning tools
  • Digital assessments and feedback systems

One of the most closely watched developments is in Utah, where legislation aimed at limiting student device use is advancing rapidly through the state legislature. Other states, including Tennessee, Missouri, Kansas, and Alabama, are also considering proposals that would place significant limits on classroom technology.

Many of these efforts stem from legitimate concerns about student well-being, excessive entertainment screen use, and the influence of social media. However, many policy discussions fail to clearly distinguish between entertainment screen use and purposeful instructional technology. This distinction matters!

Purposeful Technology Is Not the Same as Passive Screen Time

Educational technology, when implemented thoughtfully, is not about increasing screen exposure. It is about expanding access and opportunity.

Purposeful technology supports:

  • Accessibility tools that enable all students, but especially students with disabilities, to fully participate in learning
  • Translation and language supports for multilingual learners
  • Expanded access to advanced coursework for students
  • Real-time formative feedback that accelerates learning
  • Career-relevant digital literacy and workforce skills

In other words, powerful learning is a design choice, not a device count.

The policy conversation should not focus on simply reducing screens, but on ensuring that technology is used intentionally, responsibly, and transparently to support learning outcomes.

Education leaders are uniquely positioned to help shape that conversation.

Policy Momentum Can Spread Quickly

Education policy rarely stays contained within state borders. When one state adopts a new approach, other legislatures often follow. Bill language is shared, advocacy organizations replicate policy models, and national conversations amplify momentum. Ideas can spread quickly through this process.

What begins as legislation in one or two states can quickly become a broader national policy trend. For that reason, technology leaders, district administrators, and education advocates should be aware of the growing conversation about technology use in schools and prepared to engage constructively with policymakers and communities.

Engage Families in the Conversation

Local community engagement remains one of the most important ways districts can address concerns about technology use in schools. Families want and deserve transparency around how digital tools are used in classrooms and how they benefit students. Clear communication helps parents understand:

  • Why specific technologies are used
  • How student data privacy is protected
  • How instructional technology differs from entertainment screen use
  • How technology supports accessibility and personalized learning

To support these conversations, the EdTech Leaders Alliance offers a Parent Professional Learning Night program that districts can host locally to help families better understand purposeful technology use in schools. Member districts can access this program at no additional cost by contacting the ETLA team for details (email newsletters@learn21.org to learn more).

These types of conversations can help ensure that community discussions about technology are grounded in accurate information and shared understanding.

Advocacy Is Essential to Shaping Policy

In addition to local engagement, education leaders can play an important role in national policy conversations. One opportunity to do so is the annual EdTech Advocacy & Policy Fly-In, taking place April 29–30 in Washington, DC.

Organized by CoSN, SETDA, ISTE+ASCD, and SIIA, this event brings together education leaders from across the country to meet directly with policymakers and discuss the role of technology in supporting effective and equitable learning environments.

Representatives from Learn21 and the EdTech Leaders Alliance will be participating, and additional voices from districts and state organizations are always valuable in helping policymakers understand the realities of modern classrooms. Constructive advocacy helps ensure that future policy decisions reflect the perspectives of educators, students, and communities.

This Is the Moment for Education Leaders

The national conversation around screens in schools is not going away. But together we can help it evolve. Too often, policy discussions are shaped by headlines and assumptions rather than by the lived experiences of educators and students. When education leaders step forward to explain how technology is used responsibly and purposefully in classrooms, the conversation becomes more balanced and more productive.

This is the moment for education leaders to participate actively in that conversation. By thoughtfully demonstrating what purposeful technology looks like when it supports accessibility, opportunity, and learning outcomes we can reclaim the narrative.

Tell the Story Before Someone Else Does

Across the country, there are powerful stories unfolding in classrooms every day. These are not stories about “more screens”, but rather stories about expanded opportunities for students. Capturing and sharing these stories is the goal of an ongoing national project:

Purposeful Technology, Powerful Learning: You Can’t Ban Possibility.

This effort aims to document how thoughtful technology implementation is improving learning outcomes and expanding educational access across the country.

If your district has a story to share about innovation, digital literacy, cybersecurity leadership, AI implementation, accessibility, or meaningful technology integration we invite you to contribute. Because the future of educational technology will not be shaped solely by legislation. It will be shaped by the stories educators are willing to share. And those stories remind us of something important:

Technology in education is never the goal, learning is!

When technology is used with purpose, vision, and care, it becomes one of the most powerful tools we have to expand what learning can be. That is why, when the conversation turns to banning technology in schools, education leaders must respond with clarity and confidence.

Media Literacy Minute

Learn21 Media Literacy Minute logo badge surrounded by colorful icons of books, light bulbs, phones, and a globe

Helping Teens Navigate Social Media—Without Banning It

In a recent Forbes piece, public health expert Brian Castrucci outlines practical ways adults can help teens build healthier relationships with social media rather than simply removing access altogether. The strategies include treating social media like a shared public space, modeling healthy behavior, and focusing on conversations about how platforms shape attention and emotions. For educators and parents alike, the takeaway is clear: guiding students toward thoughtful, reflective use of digital spaces is often more effective than outright bans.

Why Is It So Hard to Stop Scrolling?

A thought-provoking News Decoder piece explores the question behind many students’ daily habits: why is it so difficult to put the phone down? In “Decoder Replay: We can’t stop scrolling. Whose fault is it?”, the author examines how platform design, attention economics, and personal habits all contribute to endless scrolling and the “brain rot” feeling many users describe after hours online. The article is especially useful for classroom discussion, ending with reflection questions that encourage students to think critically about their own media habits and attention.

Three Principles for Healthier Media Use

In “Pope Leo’s 3 Keys to Safe and Sensible Media Use,” the pontiff offers a surprisingly relevant framework for today’s digital world. His guidance centers on three ideas: don’t surrender your ability to think critically, guide technology rather than letting it guide you, and invest in education and literacy so people can engage with media responsibly. The message is a reminder that thoughtful media use isn’t just a technical skill—it’s a human one rooted in discernment and responsibility.

CIPA & E-Rate: What Education Leaders Need to Know

The Children's Internet Protection Act (CIPA), enacted by Congress in 2000, establishes federal requirements for schools and libraries that receive certain technology funding. For education leaders, understanding CIPA is not optional — it is a prerequisite for accessing one of the most valuable funding streams available: the E-Rate program. And of course, we are right in the middle of E-Rate season.

What CIPA Requires

CIPA mandates that schools adopt and implement an Internet safety policy that includes technology protection measures, commonly known as content filters, to block or filter visual depictions that are obscene, contain child pornography, or are harmful to minors. Beyond filtering, a compliant Internet safety policy must address:

  • Minors' online activity, including access to inappropriate content
  • The safety and security of minors in direct electronic communications (e.g., email and chat)
  • Unauthorized disclosure of personal information about minors
  • Cyberbullying and hacking, as updated by the Protecting Children in the 21st Century Act

Schools must also provide education for minors on appropriate online behavior, including interaction on social media and awareness of cyberbullying.

The E-Rate Connection

E-Rate, administered by the FCC through the Universal Service Fund, provides schools and libraries with discounts on broadband connectivity and networking equipment. The critical link: CIPA compliance is a condition of E-Rate eligibility. Schools that fail to certify compliance with CIPA's requirements cannot receive E-Rate discounts — discounts that can reach up to 90% for high-need communities.

What Leaders Should Do

Education leaders should conduct an annual review of their Internet safety policy, confirm that content filtering systems are active and effective, and ensure that digital citizenship and online safety education is embedded in the curriculum. Compliance is not a one-time checkbox — it is an ongoing obligation that protects both students and funding.

Big Ideas

Big ideas image

For this edition’s theme, we are going to focus on energy. After all, with state testing, E-Rate, and all the end of the year things, we can all use a shot of energy. More specifically, we’ll focus on the energy demands of AI, which certainly is a “charged” topic (haha).

Up, up, up

This piece from The Massachusetts Institute of Technology Technology Review argues that the real AI energy story isn't about individual users feeling guilty over chatbot queries — it's about the massive, systemic infrastructure being built around AI. Tech giants are spending hundreds of billions of dollars on data centers, with projects like the Stargate initiative and Meta's Louisiana facility representing an almost incomprehensible scale of energy investment. Data centers require constant, uninterrupted power, and research suggests they use electricity that is significantly more carbon-intensive than the national average. Energy consumption by data centers climbed 80% between 2020 and 2025 and is expected to keep rising. The article calls for greater transparency from companies like Google, Microsoft, and OpenAI, all of whom declined to share specific energy figures, and frames smarter decisions about data center locations, energy sources, and accountability as the critical challenges ahead.

Up, up, up redux

Here, the folks from the International Energy Agency (IEA) offer their take on the rise in energy consumption due to new data centers, a necessary byproduct from AI usage. They also offer some optimism, predicting that AI can unlock new efficiencies. The IEA's 2025 report projects that global electricity consumption from data centers will roughly double to around 945 TWh by 2030, growing at about 15% per year — more than four times faster than all other sectors combined. AI is the primary driver, with electricity demand from AI-optimized data centers projected to more than quadruple by 2030. The geographic impact is uneven: in the United States, data centers are on course to account for almost half of electricity demand growth to 2030; in Japan, more than half. On the supply side, renewables will meet nearly half of the additional demand, with natural gas and coal filling much of the rest in the near term, while nuclear power is expected to play a growing role after 2030.

The report also notes AI's potential upside, it could help accelerate clean energy innovation and, if widely adopted by the electricity sector, save up to $110 billion annually and unlock 175 gigawatts of transmission capacity.

Up, up and did you know?

Heading back to the folks at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology’s Sloan’s School of Management, we learn that data centers currently account for 1–2% of global energy demand, comparable to the airline industry, and that figure could hit 21% by 2030 when the full costs of delivering AI to consumers are included. By the way, did you know that when you create an image with AI, it takes the equivalent power of one full iPhone charge? Think about that next time you’re tempted to superimpose your dog’s face over a celebrity picture.

But the article is optimistic: MIT scientists argue that meaningful reductions are achievable without major capital investment. Technology team's key strategies include "power capping" — limiting processors to 60–80% of their total power capacity — which reduces both energy consumption and operating temperatures. They also built a training estimation tool that predicts model accuracy after just 20% of computation, cutting roughly 80% of compute with no impact on the final model. Additionally, carbon-aware software like MIT's Clover tool can shift non-urgent AI workloads to lower-carbon time periods or regions, reducing carbon intensity by 80–90%. Together, these approaches could shave 10–20% off global data center electricity demand. That’s a lot of dog pictures!

How Learn21 can help

Professional LearningTraining and coaching for educators and IT staff. Data Privacy ServicesStudent data privacy guidance and compliance support for K-12 districts. More Bytes and InsightsBrowse every edition by topic and year.

Never miss an edition

Join thousands of K-12 educators and tech leaders who get Bytes and Insights in their inbox every week.

Subscribe to Bytes and Insights